When all self-centered desires are lacking, prayer transforms into worship, “sublime thinking” into “superthinking” (ref. 1616 D). Otherwise they are identical where they overlap. At the point worship begins we basically just hang on for the ride, but this does not mean that our minds are quiet or without thoughts. Far from it. Our Thought Adjuster is “conducting” the worship.“The more healthful attitude of spiritual meditation is to be found in reflective worship and the prayer of thanksgiving”For us at this time (in this state) “worship is effortless attention, true and ideal soul rest, a form of restful spiritual exertion” (1616 D).“Under no circumstances should the trancelike state of visionary consciousness be cultivated as a religious experience.” (1099 D)This is because while the thoughts we have then seem to be our own, they are actually being produced -- not without our own unconscious distortions (see 1786 D) -- by our Thought Adjusters and the Spirit of Truth. Cause these thoughts to cease and communication stops!“If one is disposed to recognize a theoretical subconscious mind as a practical working hypothesis in the otherwise unified intellectual life, then, to be consistent, one should postulate a similar and corresponding realm of ascending intellectual activity as the superconscious level, the zone of immediate contact with the indwelling spirit entity, the Thought Adjuster.” (1099 C)“Ascending intellectual activity” is diametrically opposed to the stillness-minded intellectual inactivity practiced in Eastern Religion-style meditation.The only place in the whole URANTIA Book where anything at all in the nature of non-intellectual functioning, passive-minded contemplation is advanced, which I have been able to discover, is where we are instructed by Jesus that after we have made our prayers to the Father, we should “remain for a time in silent receptivity to afford the indwelling spirit the better opportunity to speak to the listening soul” (1641 A). Notice that the spirit speaks to the soul, however, and not to the mind or consciousness of the praying person. This is quite different from hearing “voices”. This is neither prayer nor worship, and it is not “meditation”. It is a few moments of quietude to be imposed before quitting! It is to augment the transition into worship over time, so that one who now merely says his prayers will later be able to continue them on into worship, which is the goal. Ideally the transition of the moment is seamless, we simply segue from the one into the other. The line between prayer and worship is self-interest. (ref. 65 D)“The ideal prayer is a form of spiritual communication which leads to intelligent worship.”Admittedly the doorway to mental quietude is cracked open by Jesus’ instruction, but hardly wide enough to admit the full panoply of Eastern-style meditation! Actually all that Jesus is saying is that we should shut up and listen for a moment after praying before returning to our ordinary thoughts and activities. There is no indication whatsoever that we can expect to be, or should become aware of any aspect of this particular transaction between our soul and Thought Adjuster, but as we more and more become our souls, that is, as we personally grow over time to identify ourselves with our higher self, the more we should obviously be able to “hear”:“The material and mortal reality of the self transcend[s] the temporal limitations of the physical-life machine and attain[s] a new expression of a new identification in the evolving vehicle for selfhood continuity, the morontia and immortal soul. (1218 D)This evolution of one’s soul/self identification cannot be achieved by any short-cut methods, including thought-stilling techniques! Jesus knew:“the futility of the Caligastia method of trying to get ahead of the natural, slow and sure way of accomplishing the divine purpose.” (1521 A)“Never, in all your ascent to Paradise, will you gain anything by impatiently attempting to circumvent the established and divine plan by short cuts, personal inventions, or other devices for improving on the way of perfection, to perfection and for eternal perfection.” (864 C)Quite plainly we are taught that:“There is no other technique [than prayer] whereby every man, regardless of all other mortal accomplishments, can so effectively and immediately approach the threshold of that realm wherein he can communicate with his maker … with the indwelling Thought Adjuster.” (1000 A)“The ideal prayer is a form of spiritual communication which leads to intelligent worship”(1618 D).“When Jesus taught his associates to pray in the spirit and in truth, he explained that he referred to praying sincerely and in accordance with one’s enlightenment, to praying wholeheartedly and intelligently, earnestly and steadfastly” (1640 C).Jesus’ instruction for a receptive moment after prayer does not appear to apply to people who are at the point of entering from prayer into worship, but rather to those whose spiritual communications seldom if ever rise to the level of worship. It appears to be a method of preparing a worshipful attitude of mind over time. This directive was presented in a list of sixteen instructions (beginning on page 1638) concerning -- except for this last point in the list -- prayer. Jesus brought that subject from the sub-level of (1) “conscious and persistent regard for iniquity”; through (3) “opening the God-man communication”; to the few moments (“a time”) of (16) “silent receptivity”. Then he touches upon the higher level of a beginning understanding of worship, which, unlike prayer, is not described in detail there. We are told that while he did teach more at this point, “not many … could fully encompass his teaching”. We should understand that Thought Adjusters at that time had not yet been universally bestowed, so worship -- including understanding of the subject -- might have been particularly difficult for these people, even though they were twenty-four of Jesus’ closest followers. This event took place, after all, during his first preaching tour of Galilee. Not long before this they were unable to grasp even more than a few of the conceptual differences between prayer and worship which Jesus attempted to teach them (ref. 1616 B). It should not be overlooked, either, that although they did have the presence of the physical Jesus, he could not be with them 24 hours a day or in their minds when they prayed, worshipped, or meditated. The Spirit of Truth would not be poured out until after Jesus’ departure.For ourselves, if we access this now universally available spirit resource, worship should come much easier -- it is obviously a stage or ability which must be attained before “worshipful meditation”, or Jesus-style meditation can take place. But stilling one’s thoughts is hardly the way to open the door to the “realm of the highest and most spiritualized thinking”.“Nothing which human nature has touched can be regarded as infallible.”
We are indeed told that mysticism, as the “technique of the cultivation of the consciousness of the presence of God” -- which is virtually identical to the 1934-1935 definition of the word -- “is altogether praiseworthy” (1000 A). But that “however favorable may have been the conditions for mystic phenomena, it should be clearly understood that Jesus of Nazareth never resorted to such methods for communication with the Paradise Father” (1100 A), and “the direct communion with one’s Thought Adjuster, such as occurred in the later years of Jesus’ life in the flesh, should not be confused with … so-called mystical experiences” (1100 A). And, as well, that when mystical practices “lead to social isolation and culminate in religious fanaticism, they are all but reprehensible. (1000 A).We are clearly and most specifically warned by The URANTIA Book that “under no circumstances should the trancelike state of visionary consciousness be cultivated as a religious experience” [this “mystical state” is defined therein as “diffusion of consciousness with vivid islands of focal attention operating on a comparatively passive intellect” -- in short, thought-stilling, so-called “meditation”] (1099 D). Rather than using the “mystical” approach -- regardless of how “praiseworthy” -- “the more healthful attitude of spiritual meditation is to be found in reflective worship and the prayer of thanksgiving”. (1100 A)Prayer, Jesus said, “is designed to make man less thinking but more realizing; it is not designed to increase knowledge but rather expand insight”(1616 C). That is, we begin to realize the truth-content of the thoughts which are formed in our minds by the work of the Spirit of Truth and our Thought Adjusters, yet which seem to be our own -- again, this hardly implies a quiet mind! It is, we are told quite plainly, our “thoughts” that lead us “Godward”. “The divine spirit makes contact with mortal man … in the realm of the highest and most spiritualized thinking” (1104 D - 1105 A). The intellect is active during worshipful meditation -- “Jesus-style meditation” -- but we are no longer in charge. This does not mean that the thoughts (as opposed to “voices” etc.) which we perceive can be expected to be entirely free of our own, personal, distortions -- they cannot! Yet these distortions will become minimized over time as we continue with the process of spiritualization (or more precisely, “morontialization”).
One of the most popular forms of passive-mind, so-called “meditation”, Transcendental Transcendental Meditation master, Marahrishi Mahesh Yogi.Meditation or TM, is in fact pitched in conformity to The URANTIA Book warning against the use of such trancelike, “mystic” states for the purpose of religious experience: “Transcendental Meditation is not a religion -- it is a technique … It supports all religions because it releases stress and purifies the mind, body, and emotions of the person who practices it.” (Maharishi Mahesh Yogi’s Transcendental Meditation: Revised and Updated Edition, by Robert Roth, 1994, Donald Fine Inc. New York) Many benefits attributed to TM, however, are also said to be attainable from prayer and worship, or Jesus-style meditation. Rodan explained how we absorb energy during spiritual communion. He also said that: “on every mountaintop of intellectual thought are to be found relaxation for the mind, strength for the soul, and communion for the spirit. From such vantage points of high living, man is able to transcend the material irritations of lower levels of thinking -- worry, jealousy, envy, revenge, and the pride of immature personality. These high-climbing souls deliver themselves from a multitude of crosscurrent conflicts of the trifles of living, thus becoming free to attain the consciousness of the higher currents of spirit concept and celestial communication. But the life purpose must be jealously guarded from the temptation to seek for easy and transient attainment … ” (1778 B) Jesus (in modern terms supplied by midwayers) compared prayer to “recharging the spiritual batteries of the soul”, and worship to “tuning in the soul to catch the universe broadcast of the infinite spirit of the Universal Father” (1621 C). It provided “true and ideal soul rest”, he maintained, and that “the strain [stress] of living should be relaxed by the restfulness of worship” (1616 B). “Kingdom … believers,” he said: “must increasingly learn how to step aside from the rush of life -- escape the harassments of material existence -- while they refresh the soul, inspire the mind, and renew the spirit by worshipful communion” (1739 D). Notice that “worshipful meditation”, as taught and practiced by Jesus, provides something that TM does not claim: it benefits the soul! Jesus-style meditation improves the whole personality, rather than just being limited to its corporal/mental parts. This is NOT to say that proponents of non-TM brands of passive-mind meditation do not, unlike the Maharishi Mahesh Yogi, claim spiritual benefits as well -- many do. The question is whether we should believe them or The URANTIA Book! “The life purpose must be jealously guarded from
the temptation to seek for easy and transient attainment”
Comments
Notes by Peter Holly